in030304

INCITS B11 Letter Ballot 2003-002 (7-0-0-0-7)

5-year Review
ANSI/ISO 15898:1998  356 mm Optical Disk Cartridges, Extended Capacity, using Phase Change Technology , for Information Interchange

Question:  Do you approve that this standard be reaffirmed for a further 5 years?

From:  Neumann, John
Sent:  Thursday, March 6, 2003 8:39 AM
To:  Bennett, Barbara
Subject:  Re: FW: B11 Letter Ballots

The answer to question 2 is NO, and questions 3 and 4 is YES.

Regards,

John

From:  Bennett, Barbara
Sent:  Wednesday, March 5, 2003 3:19 PM
To:  Neumann, John
Subject:  FW: B11 Letter Ballots
Importance:  High

John,

Concerning, ISO/IEC 15486-1998 and ISO/IEC 15898-1998, you provided the answer to Question 1 - see Question Form; however, there was no response for the answers to the other four questions.

Would you like me to send B11 a formal transmittal requesting the answers to the other four questions or do you already have the response?  If B11 has the answers then I may conduct the INCITS ballots now.

ISO/IEC 15486-1998 was adopted in 2000 and ISO/IEC 15898-1998 in 2002 - see question 3.

What are the answers to Questions 2, 4 and 5?

Barbara

----------
From:  Neumann, John
Sent:  Friday, February 28, 2003 1:28 PM
To:  Bennett, Barbara
Subject:  B11 Letter Ballots

 
Barbara,

B11 Letter ballots for reaffirmation and DIS positions have completed as per
attached document.

The results of the LB are shown in parens (7-0-0-0-7) for example.

The recommendation is the highlighted portion of the questions for each LB
(reaffirm or YES with no comments).  In the one case, two negative votes were
cast with the same reasons.  These reasons are included for completeness, but
the result of the ballot is to vote YES with no comments since the vote was
5-2-0-0-7.

Regards,

John Neumann
Chair, B11