InterNational Committee for Information Technology Standards
INCITS Secretariat, Information Technology Industry Council (ITI)
1250 Eye St. NW, Washington, DC 20005
Telephone 202-737-8888; Fax 202-638-4922
email: incits@itic.org


DOC: M1/03-0622
Date: December 30, 2003
Reply to: Fernando L. Podio
Phone: (301) 975-2947
email: fernando.podio@nist.gov

Second Draft Agenda (2-week agenda) for the 9th Meeting of INCITS Technical Committee M1, Biometrics 
Thursday 15, 9:00 AM - 5:30 PM, Friday 16, 9:00 AM - NOON, January 2004

An M1 Delegates’ Meeting (required for US delegates to the SC 37 WG meetings in February 2004, Sydney, Australia) will start immediately after M1 adjourns. If M1 adjourns Friday at NOON, the M1 Delegates Meeting will start at 1:00PM and end no later than 3:00 PM. If M1 adjourns Thursday evening, the M1 Delegates meeting will start Friday 16 at 9:00 AM and will end no later than NOON. M1 members and delegates: Please make your travel plans accordingly. 

Meeting Location

American Conference Centers
780 Third Avenue, Level C-2
New York, New York 10017
(212) 888-0888
www.americanconferencecenters.com

Hosting organization

International Biometric Group
Contact:
Carolyn Rodichok
crodichok@biometricgroup.com
Phone: 212-809-9491

REF: M1/03-0586 - Logistics Package, Meeting Announcement and Schedule of
INCITS M1 and M1 Task Groups/Ad-Hoc Group Meetings, January 12-16, 2003 – New York, NY


Agenda Point of Contact: Fernando Podio, M1 Chairman
301-975-2947, email:
fernando.podio@nist.gov

Participation in M1 meetings is open to any directly and materially affected parties

NOTE:

Organizations obtain voting rights in accordance with the INCITS Reference Document - # RD-2, Organization and Procedures http://www.incits.org/rd2/main.htm

1. Administrative

1.1 Call to Order (Mr.Podio)

1.2 Membership and Attendance

1.2.1 Introduction of Attendees and New Members

1.2.2 Membership Report (Dr. Soutar/Dr. Elliott)

    REF:

1.3 Document Distribution

INCITS M1 documents are posted in the M1 Document Register. JTC 1 SC 37 N 301 and up, posted in the JTC 1 SC 37 web site are part of this agenda.

1.4 Approval of the Draft Minutes for M1 Meeting #8 (Dr. Elliott)

    REF: M1/03-0575

1.5 Approval of the Draft Agenda

    REF: M1/03-0622


1.6 INCITS Antitrust Guidelines

   REF: http://www.incits.org/inatrust.htm

2. Chairman's Remarks (Mr. Podio)

3. M1 Task Group Brief January 2004 Meeting Reports

3.1 M1.2 Meeting Report (Mr. Herr)

        REF: 

3.2 M1.3 Meeting Report (Dr. Cambier)

        REF:  

3.3 M1.4 Meeting Report (Mr. Podio)

       REF:

3.4 M1.5 Meeting Report (Mr. Sutton)

       REF:

(National Projects)

4. INCITS M1 Task Group M1.3 on Biometrics Data Interchange Formats (Dr. Cambier)

4.1 INCITS Project: 1564-D - Finger Minutiae Format for Data Interchange (Dr. Cambier)

4.1.1 Status of INCITS 378

4.2 INCITS Project: 1563-D - Finger Pattern Based Interchange Format (Dr. Soutar)

4.2.1 Status of INCITS 377

4.3 INCITS Project: 1576-D - Iris Recognition Interchange Format - (Dr. Cambier)

4.3.1 Status of INCITS 379

4.3.1.1 For Action - Approval of TG recommendation to forward INCITS the revised draft (M1/03-590 as revised by M1.3 ) for a Second Public Review

      REF: M1/03-0590, M1/03-0595

4.4 INCITS Project: 1577-D - Finger Image Based Interchange Format (Mr. McCabe)

4.4.1 Status of INCITS 381

4.4.2 For Action - Approval of TG recommendation to forward INCITS the revised draft according to the disposition of comments in M1/03-0537 for a Second Public Review (if INCITS indicates that a Second Public Review is required).

      REF: M1/03-0414, M1/03-0537

 

4.5 INCITS Project: 1565-D - Face Recognition Format for Data Interchange (Mr. Griffin)

4.5.1 For Action - Approval of TG recommendation - TG Comment Resolution and recommendation to M1 on forwarding the draft to INCITS for Initial Public Review

        REF: M1/03-0494, M1/03-0585

4.6 INCITS Project 1603-D – Signature/Sign Image Interchange format (Mr. Beatson)

 

          REF: M1/03-0439r, M1/03-0479

 

4.6.1 Current status of the project

 

4.6.2 For Action - Approval of TG Recommendation - initiation of an M1 letter ballot on forwarding the draft as revised by the TG for Initial Public Review

        REF: M1/03-0603

4.7  Project 1643-D – Hand Geometry Interchange Format (Mr. Tamer)


4.7.1 Current status of the project



4.7.1.1 For Action - Approval of TG Recommendation - initiation of an M1 letter ballot on forwarding the draft as revised by the TG for Initial Public Review

        REF:
M1/03-0495, M1/03-0620

 


4.7.2 For Action - Approval of TG Recommendation - further action on 1643-D

 

5. INCITS M1 Task Group M1.4 on Biometric Application Profiles (Mr. Podio)

5.1 Project INCITS 1566-D - Application Profile - Interoperability and Data Interchange - Biometrics-Based Verification and Identification of Transportation Workers (Mr. Neumann)

5.1.1 Status of INCITS 378 Initial Public Review



5.2 Project NCITS 1567-D - Application Profile for Interoperability, Data Interchange and Data Integrity of Biometric Based Personal Identification for Border Crossing/Management (Mr. Herr)   

5.2.1 For Action - Approval of TG recommendation - TG Comment Resolution and recommendation to M1 on forwarding the draft to INCITS for Initial Public Review

        REF: M1/03-0557 M1/03-0583 , M1/03-0621

5.3 Project Proposal  - DoD's Biometric Application Profile (Dr. Guirguis)

5.3.1 For Action -  TG Recommendation to M1 - Approval of Project Proposal

       REF: M1/03-0588


6. M1 Ad-Hoc Group on Evaluating Multi-Biometric Systems (AHGEMS) - (Mr. Lazarick)


6.1  Report on the January 2004 Meeting


        REF: 


7. M1 Ad-Hoc Group on Cross Jurisdictional and Societal Issues (Mr. Wing)


7.1  Report on the November and December 2003 Meetings


        REF: M1/03-0607 M1/03-0608


7.2
For Action  - Establishment of an M1 Task Group on Cross Jurisdictional and Societal Issues

        REF:  M1/03-0608


8. M1 Ad-Hoc Group on Issues for Harmonizing Conformity Assessment to Biometric Standards (Mr. Hogan)

8.1  Report on the First Ad-Hoc Meeting

9. M1 Ad-Hoc Group on Vocabulary (Dr. Elliott)


9.1  Report on the January 2004 Meeting


10.
M1 Ad-Hoc Group on Sample Quality (Mr. Benini)


10.1  Report on the December 2003 Meeting

(International)

11. INCITS M1 Task Group M1.2 on Biometric Technical Interfaces (Mr. Herr)

11.1 Brief Review of LBs Results (US NB and other NB Comments), NB Technical Contributions, and NB Comments on WDs & US NB Positions for the SC 37 WG2 meeting in Sydney

11.1.1 Review of Comments on UK contribution - proposed base document on Biometric Interworking Protocol

        REF: SC 37 N 114, N204, N262, N369


11.1.2 Review of contributions on Conformance Test Metholodology for BioAPI

        REF: SC 37 N321, N372


11.1.3 US position on German Contribution - Proposed Working Draft Text for Biometrics — Biometric

Interfaces — Part 2: BioAMI – Biometric Archive Module Interface

        REF: SC 37 N 354

11.1.4 LB Results - Text of 3rd CD 19785-1, Common Biometric Exchange Formats Framework (CBEFF): Part 1: Data

Element Specification -
US position on NB comments

            REF: SC 37 N312, N352

11.1.5
Review of Technical Contributions on Conformance Testing Method & Procedure for BioAPI of ISO 19784 Part 1

            REF
: SC 37 N 372, N321


11.2 For Action - Approval of M1.2 Recommendations to M1

11.2.1 US response to FCD 19704 LB -  BioAPI specification

        REF: SC 37 N 311

11.2.2 US response to LB - NP on Multimodal Biometric Fusion

        REF: SC 37 N 351


11.2.3 US response to LB - NP on ISO/IEC 19784 Biometric Interfaces, Part 2 - BioAMI Biometric Archive Module Interface


        REF: SC 37 N 353

11.2.4 List of US experts to attend the SC37 WG2 meeting in February

11.2.5 Nomination of US representative from WG2 to WG1 (vocabulary)

         REF: SC 37 N 361 & N 314 (Resolution #3.3)

11.2.6 ISO 19092 ISO 19092, Biometric Information Management and Security for Financial Applications (Transposition of X9.84)  

11.2.6.1 Review of responses to M1/03-0435, Call for Participation

11.2.6.2 TC 68 SC 2 Position on Joint Technical Work (TC 68, SC 27 & SC 37)

        REF: SC 37 N 379 (SC 37 Laision report to TC 68), N 378 (SC 27 to SC 37 Liaison report), N 376 (JTC 1 Resolutions)

12. INCITS M1 Task Group M1.3 on Biometrics Data Interchange Formats (Dr. Cambier)

12.1 Brief Review of LBs Results (US NB and other NB Comments), NB Technical Contributions, and NB Comments on WDs & US NB Positions for the SC 37 WG3 meeting in Sydney

12.1.1 LB Results on CD ISO/IEC 19794-2, Biometric Data Interchange Formats Part 2: Finger Minutiae Data

        REF: SC 37 N 340

12.1.2 LB Results on CD ISO/IEC 19794-4, Biometric Data Interchange Formats Part 4: Finger Image Data 

          REF: SC 37 N 341

12.1.3 LB Results on CD ISO/IEC 19794-5, Biometric Data Interchange Formats Part 5: Face Image Data

        REF: SC 37 N 342

12.1.4 LB Results on CD ISO/IEC 19794-6, Biometric Data Interchange Formats Part 6: Iris Image Data

        REF: SC 37 N 339

12.1.5 US Position on Technical Contributions on Biometric Data Interchange Formats, Part 1: Framework

        REF: SC37 N 319, N 380, N337, N374

12.1.6 US Position on Comments & NB Technical Contributions on 2nd Working Draft Text for 19794-3, Biometric Data Interchange Formats - Part 3: Finger Pattern Data

        REF: SC 37 N 381 (Sweden), N 382 (Canada), N 383 (Japan), N 384 (UK), N 385 (France), N 386 (Germany), Nxxx (Consolidation of comments)

12.1.7 US Position on Comments on  WD Text of ISO/IEC 19794-7, Biometric Data Interchange Formats -Part 7: Signature/Sign Data

        REF: SC37 N 305

12.2 For Action - Approval of M1.3 Recommendations to M1

12.2.1 US position on SC 37 Expert Report on ILO/ISO meeting on Seafarers ID

        REF: SC 37 N346 (expert report), N 393 (French contrib.)

12.2.2 Nomination of US representative from WG3 to WG1 (vocabulary)

        REF: SC 37 N 361, N 314 (Resolution #3.3)

12.2.3 Recommendation to M1 on list of US experts to attend the SC37 WG3 meeting in February


12.2.4 US position on face recognition work within SC 29's MPEG group


        REF:

13 INCITS M1 Task Group M1.4 on Biometric Profiles (Mr. Podio)


13.1 Brief Review of LBs Results (US NB and other NB Comments), NB Technical Contributions, and NB Comments on WDs & US NB Positions for the SC 37 WG4 meeting in Sydney


13.1.1
LB Results on Proposal for an NP Biometric Profiles for Interoperability and Data Interchange - Part 1: Biometric Reference Architecture


        REF: SC37 N301, N 397 (ballot results)


13.1.2 LB Results on Proposal for a New Work Item for Biometric Profiles for Interoperability and Data Interchange - Part 2: Biometric Profile for Employees

        REF: SC37 N302, N 398 (ballot results)

13.1.3 US Position on Comments & NB Technical Contributions on Biometric Profiles for Interoperability and Data Interchange - Part 1: Biometric Reference Architecture

        REF: SC37 N363

13.1.4 US Position on Comments & NB Technical Contributions on Biometric Profiles for Interoperability and Data Interchange - Part 2: Biometric Profile for Employees

        REF: SC37 N364

13.2 For Action - Approval of M1.4 Recommendations to M1

13.2.1 US position on SC 37 Expert Report on ILO/ISO meeting on Seafarers ID.

        REF: SC 37 N346 (expert report), N393 (French contrib.), N376 (JTC 1 Resolutions - Singapore)

13.2.2 Nomination of US representative from WG4 to WG1 (vocabulary)

        REF: SC 37 N361, N314 (Resolution #3.3)

13.2.3 Recommendation to M1 on list of US experts to attend the SC37 WG4 meeting in February.

13.2.4 Recommendation to M1 on US NB Position on Document from JTC 1/SC 27 - 1st Working Draft 19792, "A framework for security evaluation and testing of biometric technology"


        REF: SC 37 N 396

14 INCITS M1 Task Group M1.5 on Biometric Performance Testing (Mr. Sutton)


14.1 Brief Review of LBs Results (US NB and other NB Comments), NB Technical Contributions, and NB Comments on WDs & US NB Positions for the SC 37 WG5 meeting in Sydney


14.1.1 US Position on German contribution on
Biometric Performance Testing

        REF: SC 37 N 365

14.1.2
US position on the status of for 19795 Parts 1-4

       REF:

14.2 For Action - Approval of M1.5 Recommendations to M1

14.2.1 Nomination of US representative from WG5 to WG1 (vocabulary)

        REF: SC 37 N 361, N 314 (Resolution #3.3)

14.2.2 Recommendation to M1 on list of US experts to attend the SC37 WG4 meeting in February


14.3 Recommendation to M1 on US NB Position on Document from JTC 1/SC 27 - 1st Working Draft 19792,

"A framework for security evaluation and testing of biometric technology"


        REF: SC 37 N396


14.4
US contribution to WG5 on Biometric Performance Testing Requirements

REF: M1/03-0602

15. For Action - Approval of Ad-Hoc Group Recommendations to M1

15.1 M1 Ad-Hoc Group on Vocabulary (Dr. Elliott)

15.1.1
Recommendation to M1 -  US position on other contributions

        REF: SC 37 N 142 (SC 36 Liaison to SC 37)

15.1.2 Recommendation to M1 on list of US experts to attend the SC37 WG1 meeting in February

        REF: SC 37 N 361

15.2 M1 Ad-Hoc Group on Cross Jurisdictional and Societal Issues (Mr. Wing)

15.2.1 Recommendation to M1 - 
  LB Results on SC 37 N 309 NP on Cross Jurisdictional TR - US position on NB comments

        REF: SC 37 N 309, N 320, N 366, N371 (Australian Contrib.), N 399 (ballot results)

15.2.2 Nomination of US representative from WG6 to WG1 (vocabulary)

        REF: SC 37 N 361, N 314 (Resolution #3.3)

15.2.3 Recommendation to M1 on list of US experts to attend the SC37 WG6 meeting in February

16. Other US positions

16.1
For Action - Approval of the US Position on the Draft Report of the SC 37 Rapporteur Group Meeting on Conformity Assessment, 15-16 January 2003 in NYC


        REF: SC 37 N 395, M1/03-0611

16.2
For Action - Approval of Nomination of US expert to represent SC 37 at the JTC1 study group on privacy technology (Mrs. Tilton)

        REF: SC 37 N 391,
M1/03-0609

16.3 For Action - Approval Nomination of US expert to represent SC 37 at the JTC1 study group on web services (Mrs. Tilton)

        REF: SC 37 N 392, M1/03-0609

17. Other Business


17.1 Nomination of M1 representatives to INCITS Ad-Hoc Groups


17.1.1 INCITS Ad-Hoc Group on Privacy Technology


        REF: M1/03-0612


17.1.2 INCITS Ad-Hoc Group on Web Services


        REF: M1/03-0613


17.2 Update on National and International IP-Related Activities, Amy A. Marasco, ANSI General Counsel

(4:00 PM Thursday 15th)


17.3 Smart Card Biometric Interoperability Study Report

17.3.1 Letter to INCITS B10 on suggested actions

      REF:

18. Future M1 Meetings and Hosts

       REF:

19. Adjournment